Skip to main content
The Independent Critic

Menashe Lustig, Ruben Nyborg
Joshua Z. Weinstein
Joshua Z. Weinstein, Alex Lipschultz, and Musa Syeed
Rated PG
82 Mins.
A24 Films

 "Menashe" Opens in Indy on August 25th  
Add to favorites

I will admit that on more than one occasion while watching Menashe that I found myself thinking about the Sean Penn-led film I Am Sam, a flawed yet impactful drama about a father with an intellectual disability fighting for the right to raise his own daughter. Menashe (Menashe Lustig), the title character in the film of the same name, doesn't have an intellectual disability but he is a Hasidic Jew in Brooklyn who struggles with a faith that requires he relinquish custody of his son (Ruben Nyborg) when he unexpectedly becomes a widow. 

The first narrative feature for Joshua Z. Weinstein, up to now a documentarian, Menashe possesses a doc feeling to it as it tells the story of Menashe, inspired by Lustig's own experiences and often shot secretly in Hasidic neighborhoods. The Menashe in Menashe is a hapless grocery clerk, the kind of father whom it is easy to believe would actually have to fight to retain custody of his child as he's often late to vital importants, frequently screws up at work, drinks a bit too much, and often seems to pale in comparison to the aunt and uncle whom the rabbi has ordered the son to live with until Menashe is able to remarry. 

Menashe was filmed in Yiddish, another simple yet marvelous stroke of authenticity, and Weinstein's decision to make the film utilizing non-actors has given it this wonderfully natural aura that makes us feel like we're seeing a part of the Hasidic life seldom, if ever, captured on the big screen. Lustig's performance is quietly appealing, though he's wisely not ever a man we're completely sympathetic with as it's nearly impossible to not reach the conclusion that, just perhaps, Menashe genuinely is ill-equipped for being a single parent and, despite the idea of such a strict edict feeling almost bizarre in a nation filled to the brim with single parents, the rabbi's directions may truly be in the best interest of the child. 

Menashe is an easygoing, heartfelt comedy held together by a thread of tenderness that stretches throughout the nearly 90-minute film. It's rather extraordinary to see such a wonderful man also be such a wonderful screw-up in a culture that is seldom portrayed for the fullness of its humanity on screen. You may not always like the man Menashe, but the odds are pretty strong that you'll find yourself constantly rooting for him even as an undercurrent of resignation plays throughout the film. Weinstein doesn't force greeting card happy endings on us, but instead crafts a story that examines faith, the difficulties of parenting, and authentic understanding. 

© Written by Richard Propes
The Independent Critic 

    The 50/50 x 2020 Pledge

    The Independent Critic is proud to support Indy-based Heartland Film by committing to the 50/50 - By the end of the year 2021, The Independent Critic will achieve gender parity in its reviews of both shorts and feature films. Furthermore, The Independent Critic also pledges support for the Ruderman Family Foundation's call for authentic representation of people with disabilities in film and actively commits to leverage its journalistic influence to effect genuine change in the film industry by calling for and actively promoting authentic and inclusive casting and hiring of people with disabilities.

    our twitterour facebook page pintrestlinkdin

    The Independent Critic © 2008 - 2021